"Add H atoms" buggy in Marvin 3.4pre6

User 870ab5b546

23-06-2004 18:32:49

In Marvin 3.4pre6, if Edit -> H atoms -> Add is chosen, and the structure has an atom with a charge or a radical and an incomplete valency (so that it needs at least one additional H atom), an "internal error" is generated. (If the atom already has its complete valency, no error is generated.)





To see the error, draw cyclohexane, make one C atom charged or a radical, and try Edit -> H atoms -> Add.





P.S. The error doesn't occur if the H atoms are added in 3D instead of in 2D. (That is, Edit -> Clean -> 3D -> Clean in 3D has not been chosen in the current session, or Edit -> Clean -> 2D -> Clean in 2D has been chosen more recently.) Weird.

ChemAxon 43e6884a7a

24-06-2004 18:03:17

It seems this bug was just temporary, because it works with the version on our CVS. Thanks for the report.


Ferenc

User 870ab5b546

25-06-2004 17:16:07

Ferenc wrote:
It seems this bug was just temporary, because it works with the version on our CVS.
I don't know what you mean by "temporary", and I don't know what CVS is, but I'm able to reproduce the bug using the Marvin at http://www.chemaxon.com/test/marvin/doc/dev/example-sketch1.1.html.

ChemAxon 43e6884a7a

25-06-2004 19:27:01

Very sorry, I was not clear. We haven't replaced the version on the site yet, but on our local server the bug doesn't exist anymore.


Best regards,


Ferenc